Difference between revisions of "MTS2:Creator Guidelines/Updates and Remixes of Creations"

Revision as of 20:00, 12 January 2012

Fixing Broken Creations

Creators come and go. They lose interest with the game, they get busy with real life, or they just don't feel like updating anymore. And that's fine, but it's an awful shame to leave their creations to the entropy of patches, un-updated and useless because the creator is gone. If a custom item is broken in some way by a patch or update, then someone else can come along and update it, and share the updated version here at MTS.

However, this is subject to certain conditions:

• The original creator must have been inactive for a period of at least 1 month, and has not stated when they will be returning (for vacation or personal reasons, etc.)

• The original creator cannot have posted policies specifically forbidding updating or editing their mods. If they have no stated policy regarding updating, it's okay.

• The original creator hasn't said on the upload or in their journal that they are working on an update.

• Updates to items can be simple bugfixes or updates to work with the new patch(es)/expansion(s), or they can also include new features.

• When sharing the update here, the updater must link and credit the original creator by name prominently in their upload, and make it clear that it is an update, not an original item of their own making. Just saying "based on (link)" is not enough. The link and credit should read something like this:

• Staff will edit the original, non-updated upload to add a prominent message on the top of the main description to link to the new, updated version of the mod so that people will know where to get an updated version.

• If the original creator returns and the updates made to their creation are simply to fix it to work with a new patch/expansion (i.e. no new features added), they can use the updated version in their own thread (download it from the updated thread, attach it to their old thread, and remove the update notice), with credit and a link to the updater's profile. No sense in doing the same work twice. This doesn't apply if there have been new features added. If the updater has added new features, then they can maintain their version separately, or work something out between the two of them with the original creator.

Remixes Of Abandoned Works

Some of the coolest creations grow from a modification of someone else's work. By "remix" we mean basically any modification of the creator's work - using their textures or meshes, converting from one game to another, or including as part of a lot upload.

In the past, we've required either permission or a stated policy that says you can "remix." But many creators disappear, have no policies or unclear policies, and you can't ask permission because you can't contact them. In light of this, we allow "remixes" of other creators' work, even if you don't necessarily have permission and their policies don't state you can.

There are certain conditions on the "remix" policy:

• The original creator must have been gone for a period of at least 6 months. On MTS, this will make the orange banner show up on their posts, stating that creator has been inactive and their work is unsupported.

• The original creator does not have policies (either on their profile or in their posts) stating that you cannot do whatever type of remix you're doing.

• You must provide a link back to the original creator's profile/creation in the text of your post, and state what you've used. Just saying "Based on this: (link)" is not enough - you need to state the creator's name, the name of what you've used by them and how (mesh, textures, whatever), and a link back to them.

If you don't like the idea of your work being edited...

We understand if you feel protective of your work, or find the idea of someone "messing with" your stuff uncomfortable. That's why we will be careful not to allow things that you've said you don't want.

If you're uploading here on MTS, you can edit your policies. These policies show on your profile, and MTS staff will check your policies before anything based on your work is approved. If the options there are insufficient for you, under Edit Profile, you can type in the "About Me / Policy / Other Text" with whatever your wishes are, if you wish to restrict edits of your work.

On other sites, how you state your policies may vary, but at the very least you can always put "My policies are:" and an explanation in the text of your upload.

If your policies say you cannot do something without permission, then we will not approve something based on your work without permission!

If you care about what people do with your work, then you should also care enough to put up a policy explaining your wishes.